‘My Goodness – He Looks So Different’: Where This Child Star Deemed as Gay Disappeared to after ‘Home Improvement’

“Home Improvement” was a cultural phenomenon in the 1990s. The show brought laughter into millions of American homes. At the center of this success was a young actor whose charm and boyish good looks made him an instant fan favorite. But despite his early success, he made the shocking decision to walk away from Hollywood.

The years have been kind yet mysterious to this former child star. Whispers of his struggles with the pressures of fame, the incessant speculation about his personal life, and his eventual decision to prioritize education over acting have left many questions unanswered. Who was this star, and why did he choose such a drastically different path?

Early 1990s to 2000s

Before he became a household name, this young actor was just a regular kid from Sacramento with a flair for the camera. At seven, he started working as a model. He appeared in print advertisements and soon transitioned to TV commercials for well-known brands like Kellogg’s and Mattel.

His natural charm and boyish good looks made him a favorite among casting directors. Therefore, it wasn’t long before he landed his first TV role in the special “The Bradys” in 1990. It was clear from the beginning that he had the charisma needed to captivate an audience, even at such a young age.

His big break came in 1991 when he landed the role that would change his life forever. He was cast on the hit sitcom “Home Improvement.”

The casting directors were searching for a young actor who could hold his own alongside Tim Allen, the show’s lead, and they found just that in this boy. His striking resemblance to Allen sealed the deal, and soon he was playing the middle child in the Taylor family. His portrayal quickly made him one of the most recognizable faces on television.

By the early 1990s, this young star was everywhere. In addition to his role in “Home Improvement,” he provided the voice for Young Simba in Disney’s blockbuster “The Lion King.” Both roles further solidified his status as a teen idol.

His performances, combined with his clean-cut image, endeared him to a massive fan base. Soon, he was receiving an overwhelming 50,000 letters from fans each month. Magazines like “Bop” and “16” couldn’t get enough of him, featuring him on their covers and chronicling his every move.

Yet, as the spotlight grew brighter, so did the pressures that came with it. Despite his fame, the young actor began to feel the strain of constantly being in the public eye.

“You can’t be trapped in this bubble called the acting industry,” he once said, yearning to escape the neurotic and often bizarre world of Hollywood. He longed for normalcy, a life where he could just be himself—a regular kid who played basketball with his friends and wasn’t always in the limelight.

As the years passed, the young actor’s relationship with fame became increasingly complicated. While “Home Improvement” was a massive success, the demands of the show began to take a toll on him physically and mentally.

His schedule was grueling, with nine-and-a-half-hour days on set, which included time for schoolwork, leaving him little room for a normal childhood. The stress even led to frequent migraines, a clear sign that the pressures were becoming too much to bear.

By the mid to late 1990s, despite his growing discomfort with the spotlight, he remained committed to his fans, understanding that they were a significant part of his success. However, maintaining this connection wasn’t always easy.

The constant attention from adoring fans, especially young girls, sometimes felt overwhelming, making it difficult for him to lead any semblance of a normal life. Despite his gratitude, the burden of fame was evident.

He was often the subject of gossip and speculation, particularly regarding his personal life. During a 1998 interview with Jay Leno, Leno directly asked him about persistent rumors questioning his sexuality.

Despite the pressure, he calmly denied being gay, though he expressed frustration at having his personal life scrutinized so closely.

In 1999, the tension reached a peak when he made the controversial decision to leave “Home Improvement” before the show’s final season. His departure shocked fans and his co-stars alike, particularly Tim Allen, who was reportedly upset by the sudden exit.

Although the actor cited a desire to focus on his education as the reason for leaving, rumors swirled that there was more to the story. Allen himself expressed confusion, suggesting that perhaps the young star had been receiving conflicting advice.

Whatever the reasons, the fallout was clear: the once close-knit cast was left with unresolved feelings, particularly as the young actor chose not to return for the series finale, a move that many, including his TV mom, Patricia Richardson, found disappointing.

2000 to 2023

After leaving “Home Improvement,” the young actor made it clear that he was ready for a different path. He wanted to do something that didn’t involve the pressures of Hollywood.

In 2000, he took on roles that challenged the rumors about his sexuality. He played a gay hustler in the indie film “Speedway Junky” and a gay-bashing victim in the TV movie “Common Ground.”

Despite the rumors, his willingness to take on these roles demonstrated his commitment to his craft and desire to break away from his teen heartthrob image.

But it wasn’t just the roles that marked his departure from the Hollywood scene. He also turned his focus toward education, attending prestigious institutions like Harvard, Columbia, and St. Andrew’s University in Scotland.

In interviews, he spoke fondly of his time spent in libraries, surrounded by books and fellow students. He described his time as a student as a novel experience, relishing the opportunity to learn and explore the world outside of acting.

By 2011, he had largely disappeared from the public eye, reemerging only occasionally for events like the “Home Improvement” cast reunion.

His co-stars hadn’t seen him in years, making his participation in the reunion all the more special. Though he hadn’t completely abandoned his TV career, making guest appearances on shows like “Veronica Mars” and “Smallville,” his priorities had clearly shifted away from the limelight.

As the years passed, this former child star remained a figure of curiosity, especially for those who grew up watching him on “Home Improvement.”

In 2013, after nearly a decade away from the spotlight, he reappeared in Los Angeles. However, he was now focused on directing, writing scripts, and enjoying the simpler pleasures of life like watching movies, hiking, and staying up on shows and theater.

Despite his low profile, his legacy as Hollywood’s Jonathan Taylor Thomas, or JTT, as fans fondly called him remained intact. His co-stars from “Home Improvement” continued to speak highly of him.

In 2018, it was revealed that he was still in touch with his on-screen brothers, Zachery Ty Bryan and Taran Noah Smith. Bryan even discussed the possibility of collaborating on a project.

This was a reassuring sign for fans that, while he may have stepped away from the spotlight, his connections and friendships in the industry remained strong.

Then, in 2021, after nearly a decade away from the public eye, Thomas was seen in Los Angeles, walking his dogs in a rare public outing. By now, he had fully embraced a life away from fame, looking every bit the regular guy, far removed from the teen idol image that once defined him.